I wish you had included stats on enactment of voucher legislation, which eliminates separation of church and state. Almost every red state has vouchers, and they are as unpopular among red state voters as abortion restrictions. In red states that have held referenda, voters reject them by large margins. But the legislatures in Arizona, Florida, and Utah simply ignored the voters.
“Note that the Red state maternal mortality rate of 28.5 per 100,000 births would place it 42nd out of 48 OECD nations, between China and Argentina.4 “
This is shocking and should be stated more. It’s unacceptable that women in these states aren’t as safe as women in other states in the United States of America.
This will be a driving force in the elections in ‘24. The gop is the figurative dog that caught the car when it comes to abortion and FORCED BIRTH.
We as individuals should be the only ones who choose the trajectory of our own lives. Not anyone else. Live and let live goddamnit.
Yes, I agree, but if you wanna live and let live, you sure as hell better get out of red states, or better yet, leave the United States entirely.
For reference, I live in Mexico, having left the deteriorating USA behind. In Mexico the maternal mortality rate, while far from ideal at 25 per 100,000, at least is markedly better than that of Red AmeriKKKa.
The degree to which youth in red America separates from their parents' generation I suspect will depend on their ability to escape from their parents' evangelical churches.
The challenge with claiming that there is such a political divide between two groups of states is that the "two nations" thesis can't explain historical changes. 30 years go, California was far from the reliable blue state it is today; and it was only a few cycles ago that Florida was a swing state. Today's WaPo article on how parties target states in presidential campaigns is a good illustration of this (Gift link: https://wapo.st/3uPgTWd).
I absolutely worry about the effects of GOP control in the Southeast -- that's where poor people don't have access to expanded Medicaid, and it's the heart of anti-abortion policies right now. But it's not inevitable, as Georgia's statewide votes have shown in 2020 and 2022. Imagine, for example, if Beto O'Rourke hadn't tried to challenge Ted Cruz or Greg Abbott, but instead gone directly after Lt. Gov. Patrick. I think he'd have had a good shot in both years, and since the Texas Lt Gov controls the state senate agenda, things would be very different now. That's an individual choice of Beto's, that he went for shinier brass rings rather than an office that could've benefited Texans much more clearly.
I think another divide is a generational one. Young people see the world very differently than older people for the most part. It seems technology may broaden this as young people have so much more information via the internet. It would be very interesting to compare ideology of red nation to blue nation through the lens of our youth. Little things like young women demanding an education so as not to be tied to domestic chores or the support of a partner is showing up as women dominating college enrollment. This flip is in our younger generation. And it seems the acceptance of the LGBTQ community is higher in our youth. As well they seem united in protecting our environment given they will be living in the world long after the older generation dominating our politics right now are gone. It would be so interesting to fast forward 20 years to see how our country is then. Alas the change to an authoritarian society may prolong this seeming wave of progress for our future.
Reading this in September 2026 from canada. Explains why we’re seeing economic coercion, which I’m now convinced we must plan on being around for a very long time
I’m going to study this. The article provokes insight but my challenge is how to use what I’m learning in an actionable way. Rather than read and move on, how can I use this knowledge to make a difference.
This is a great piece, very thorough and clear-eyed and well-supported with evidence. So rare these days; thank you!
I wonder whether the data look even more stark if one divides states like VA, IL, AZ, OR, WA into Blue/Red geographic territories? (Northeast VA vs western and southern parts of VA; Northern vs Southern AZ and IL, east-west in WA and OR). If we ever declare/reorganize into new nations, might these splits would be culturally/practically meaningful to discern/identify?
I think I understand your Red vs Blue "Nation" concept, where you're looking at two distinct demographics regardless of location, but I'm not clear on the legitimacy, or value, of reifying that back into Red/Blue "States".
Doesn't your own data on urban vs rural divide and voter representation show that there aren't really any states where you can say "that state is uniformly red/blue at an elector level". Yes, there are states where the levers of power (ie the "trifecta") are held by one party or the other but in many of those states those in power don't represent the will of *their* voters, let alone the opposition voters who reside in their state.
What's the utility of the red/blue STATE construct?
Sure, you can label "State X" as "Red", if you add a big caveat of "* if you ignore the overwhelmingly Blue 2 million voters in large urban area Z".
IMHO the Red/Blue State thesis serves only one argument - succession (or partition if you prefer).
Let the Confederate Dumbocracy rise again, or let the wealthier, healthier and better educated States take their ball (and tax dollars) home and go do their own thing as Pacifica, Cascadia, or whatever political construct they prefer.
But since their aren't really any Red/Blue *STATES* this would either end up in zero representation for the Red/Blue voters (or cities and counties) left behind when their mythical Red/Blue State succeeds (or is forcefully partitioned from the now Disunited States).
Or do you follow the disastrous example of the partition of India and Pakistan with forced migration, violence, and generational hatred?
Or Civil War, with ethnic cleansing along racial and religious lines. There are too many examples to count around the world of how badly that turns out, from Rwanda, to Bosnia, to Northern Ireland.
I honestly struggle to see any pathway forward for the United States where the Red/Blue State construct helps rather than hinders.
For me, the only construct that helps is "United we Stand, Divided we Fall" but if I'm honest I don't see any viable path forward in the post-Trump era.
Certainly the USA is finished in any global leadership role, other than via outright coercion via economic and military means (which is outside of my definition of "leadership", anyway). And given the looming dollar and bond crisis, and the utter failure of the US Military to achieve any actual outcomes in Iran, both of those levers won't exist for much longer, either.
I am both impressed with your research and horrified by what it tells us about our country. While all of your data simply provide evidence to what I’m sure many of us readers already realized, seeing it so effectively presented still comes as a shock.
I truly enjoyed reading this essay! While I knew most of the bits and pieces, I've never really seen them connected in this way, and frankly, I'm included to agree with the basic premise.
P.S. Loved, LOVED the generous use of graphs; they really helped to clarify the individual points.
You wrote: "The original colonies were settled by very different peoples, who came to the 'New World' for very different reasons and sought to accomplish very different things."
Why no mention of Colin Woodard's book America Nations? It expertly lays out the historical sources of the regional cultural differences that have created the current Red-Blue divide that you describe so well.
Michael,
I wish you had included stats on enactment of voucher legislation, which eliminates separation of church and state. Almost every red state has vouchers, and they are as unpopular among red state voters as abortion restrictions. In red states that have held referenda, voters reject them by large margins. But the legislatures in Arizona, Florida, and Utah simply ignored the voters.
Diane Ravitch
This is a great suggestion, thank you!
“Note that the Red state maternal mortality rate of 28.5 per 100,000 births would place it 42nd out of 48 OECD nations, between China and Argentina.4 “
This is shocking and should be stated more. It’s unacceptable that women in these states aren’t as safe as women in other states in the United States of America.
This will be a driving force in the elections in ‘24. The gop is the figurative dog that caught the car when it comes to abortion and FORCED BIRTH.
We as individuals should be the only ones who choose the trajectory of our own lives. Not anyone else. Live and let live goddamnit.
Yes, I agree, but if you wanna live and let live, you sure as hell better get out of red states, or better yet, leave the United States entirely.
For reference, I live in Mexico, having left the deteriorating USA behind. In Mexico the maternal mortality rate, while far from ideal at 25 per 100,000, at least is markedly better than that of Red AmeriKKKa.
The degree to which youth in red America separates from their parents' generation I suspect will depend on their ability to escape from their parents' evangelical churches.
The challenge with claiming that there is such a political divide between two groups of states is that the "two nations" thesis can't explain historical changes. 30 years go, California was far from the reliable blue state it is today; and it was only a few cycles ago that Florida was a swing state. Today's WaPo article on how parties target states in presidential campaigns is a good illustration of this (Gift link: https://wapo.st/3uPgTWd).
I absolutely worry about the effects of GOP control in the Southeast -- that's where poor people don't have access to expanded Medicaid, and it's the heart of anti-abortion policies right now. But it's not inevitable, as Georgia's statewide votes have shown in 2020 and 2022. Imagine, for example, if Beto O'Rourke hadn't tried to challenge Ted Cruz or Greg Abbott, but instead gone directly after Lt. Gov. Patrick. I think he'd have had a good shot in both years, and since the Texas Lt Gov controls the state senate agenda, things would be very different now. That's an individual choice of Beto's, that he went for shinier brass rings rather than an office that could've benefited Texans much more clearly.
I think another divide is a generational one. Young people see the world very differently than older people for the most part. It seems technology may broaden this as young people have so much more information via the internet. It would be very interesting to compare ideology of red nation to blue nation through the lens of our youth. Little things like young women demanding an education so as not to be tied to domestic chores or the support of a partner is showing up as women dominating college enrollment. This flip is in our younger generation. And it seems the acceptance of the LGBTQ community is higher in our youth. As well they seem united in protecting our environment given they will be living in the world long after the older generation dominating our politics right now are gone. It would be so interesting to fast forward 20 years to see how our country is then. Alas the change to an authoritarian society may prolong this seeming wave of progress for our future.
Reading this in September 2026 from canada. Explains why we’re seeing economic coercion, which I’m now convinced we must plan on being around for a very long time
Wowee. This is one of the best researched and displayed articles I have read. Thank you for your work informing us.
I’m going to study this. The article provokes insight but my challenge is how to use what I’m learning in an actionable way. Rather than read and move on, how can I use this knowledge to make a difference.
This is a great piece, very thorough and clear-eyed and well-supported with evidence. So rare these days; thank you!
I wonder whether the data look even more stark if one divides states like VA, IL, AZ, OR, WA into Blue/Red geographic territories? (Northeast VA vs western and southern parts of VA; Northern vs Southern AZ and IL, east-west in WA and OR). If we ever declare/reorganize into new nations, might these splits would be culturally/practically meaningful to discern/identify?
I think I understand your Red vs Blue "Nation" concept, where you're looking at two distinct demographics regardless of location, but I'm not clear on the legitimacy, or value, of reifying that back into Red/Blue "States".
Doesn't your own data on urban vs rural divide and voter representation show that there aren't really any states where you can say "that state is uniformly red/blue at an elector level". Yes, there are states where the levers of power (ie the "trifecta") are held by one party or the other but in many of those states those in power don't represent the will of *their* voters, let alone the opposition voters who reside in their state.
What's the utility of the red/blue STATE construct?
Sure, you can label "State X" as "Red", if you add a big caveat of "* if you ignore the overwhelmingly Blue 2 million voters in large urban area Z".
IMHO the Red/Blue State thesis serves only one argument - succession (or partition if you prefer).
Let the Confederate Dumbocracy rise again, or let the wealthier, healthier and better educated States take their ball (and tax dollars) home and go do their own thing as Pacifica, Cascadia, or whatever political construct they prefer.
But since their aren't really any Red/Blue *STATES* this would either end up in zero representation for the Red/Blue voters (or cities and counties) left behind when their mythical Red/Blue State succeeds (or is forcefully partitioned from the now Disunited States).
Or do you follow the disastrous example of the partition of India and Pakistan with forced migration, violence, and generational hatred?
Or Civil War, with ethnic cleansing along racial and religious lines. There are too many examples to count around the world of how badly that turns out, from Rwanda, to Bosnia, to Northern Ireland.
I honestly struggle to see any pathway forward for the United States where the Red/Blue State construct helps rather than hinders.
For me, the only construct that helps is "United we Stand, Divided we Fall" but if I'm honest I don't see any viable path forward in the post-Trump era.
Certainly the USA is finished in any global leadership role, other than via outright coercion via economic and military means (which is outside of my definition of "leadership", anyway). And given the looming dollar and bond crisis, and the utter failure of the US Military to achieve any actual outcomes in Iran, both of those levers won't exist for much longer, either.
According to the data, the narrative that social media divided us is not true, it only amplified the divide that already existed. Thought provoking.
I am both impressed with your research and horrified by what it tells us about our country. While all of your data simply provide evidence to what I’m sure many of us readers already realized, seeing it so effectively presented still comes as a shock.
Cry, the beloved country…..
The map of states that have not adopted Medicaid Expansion bears a strong resemblance to the map of the Confederacy.
I truly enjoyed reading this essay! While I knew most of the bits and pieces, I've never really seen them connected in this way, and frankly, I'm included to agree with the basic premise.
P.S. Loved, LOVED the generous use of graphs; they really helped to clarify the individual points.
Fantastic and well-documented post.
You wrote: "The original colonies were settled by very different peoples, who came to the 'New World' for very different reasons and sought to accomplish very different things."
Why no mention of Colin Woodard's book America Nations? It expertly lays out the historical sources of the regional cultural differences that have created the current Red-Blue divide that you describe so well.
Typo: the LA country is Colombia not Columbia